Connected ideas

I come up with an idea or a concept and then the people around me trash it. It’s the way of things and I take it to mean that I need to find people like me, rather than naysayers and the like.

I have written on here about growing plants up walls to reduce the need for air conditioning in summer. I tend to think of this as putting on sun screen in summer and taking it off in winter. Buildings by themselves don’t do that very well in my opinion. Indeed from living in two Tokyo apartments I’ve come to the conclusion that the architects should call themselves solar oven designers and admit they’re in bed with the air conditioning and heater salesmen.

Now people who read my blog and have listened to me talk about this subject sometimes send me links that parallel the kind of thing I am talking about.

This first one was sent to me by my designer brother.

Click to access green.pdf

As you can see it’s basically my idea of growing something up a wall. They have it running like a conveyer belt though and so it seems designed for industrial use.  Additionally, they focus only on growing food in vertical spaces and its aesthetic appeal.

I see a few problems with this.

First, you need two panes of glass on the outside of the building so it’s not something you can retrofit. It seems designed for office buildings rather than homes and for annual crops instead of perennials.

Offices are where you work not where you cook. You cook at home with plants which are close at hand. Besides the people who have the time and inclination to take care of these plants would be the elderly, the housebound, and home makers.

Second if you wish to clean air then the plants which do that best are not the ones you eat. There is a talk on TED.com by Kamal Meattle about this. If you want to clean air inside a building, have the plants, in this case Areca Palm, Mother in Law’s tongue and Money Plant, inside the building.  The TED talk is here:

http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/kamal_meattle_on_how_to_grow_your_own_fresh_air.html

Additionally, having floor to ceiling windows means its not thermally efficient. If you wish thermal efficiency then you should opt for straw bale construction, or rammed earth.  If you still wish to let more light in then I’d probably use Maerogel (interestingly this product is not the market yet).

So anyway that’s my take on this plant big wheel. If you want to put plants on the side of a building, use a vine, give it something to climb, like a net. Lower the whole supporting structure like a sail on a ship when you want to harvest. Make it a die back perennial such that the building absorbs as much sunshine as possible in winter (you could even have a dark colored wall) on a south facing in the sure and certain knowledge that it would be shaded when a black wall became a liability instead of an asset. I’d tend to go with Air Potato or a hardy kiwi.

Now onto the second thing I was sent recently;  this by my good friend Taylor:

Secret Garden: Orchard on Home Rooftop

Here we have an architect’s idea of connecting flat roofs, with gardens, across multiple dwellings.  It’s a good one as far as it goes.  If it were me you would have plants down the side of the building, as well as a gazebo up for socializing. Designs like this are just crying out for sun loving plants, shade tolerant plants, vines, raised beds for annuals etc. Being architects all they do is stick something vaguely green on it. They need to expand their horizons and work on things from a multidisciplinary perspective.

The Amazing Air Potato

I was reading Eric Toensmeier’s amazing book “Perennial Vegetables – from Artichoke to Zuiki Taro, a gardener’s guide to over 100 delicious, easy to grow  edibles”, when I came across the air potato.

It’s basically a vine that grows up to 4o feet high, that instead of having tubers in the ground like a potato plant puts them on its branches like a hardy kiwi. It throws out an enormous quantity of these aerial tubers over a period of some months so that you have truly lengthy harvesting season.  Great if you’re looking for self sufficiency, or supplying a small but constant stream to a farmer’s market, in a local park, not so great if you’re a farmer wanting a fast succession of plants and a short harvest season. Makes it ideal in cities.

Another things that really interested me was that it seems ideal for growing up the outside of fire escapes in apartment buildings,  or up windowless walls.  Shade a building like that in the torrid heat of a Tokyo summer and you could turn your air conditioning down a tad.

I  swear Japanese architects are solar oven enthusiasts conspiring with air conditioning salesmen and the electricity companies to fleece the general public.  I walk out the door and it’s ten degrees cooler outside the house than in.

Now here’s what I’m thinking. You want a dark wall in winter, so that it captures as much solar heat as it can and helps keep the building warm. You want a light coloured wall in summer so that it reflects all the heat. However a vine that grows like crazy in the spring and shades the wall does a better job than white paint.

Turn down your air conditioner.

And when summer is over and the temperature drops the vine dies all the way down to its roots. Well then, the black wall is then revealed and absorbs solar radiation warming the building in the process.

Turn down the heating.

So with one plant and a dark wall you’ve got yourself a potato field that feeds you for five months.

You’ve also got a massive plant for  feeding to earthworms and black soldier fly when it dies back in winter, which in turn feeds the fish in your aquaponics system.

You’ve also got an AC cost reduction system in summer.

You’ve also got a heating cost reduction system.

That’s one plant, one wall/fire escape.

Think what you could if you could extend this thinking to every balcony, every rooftop.

I looked around and came across a site talking about this plant and its relations. It was actually pretty funny. If you grow it in the wrong place it can be a nightmare. Everyone who grows it in Florida regrets it, frothing at the mouth about how horrible it is.

Everyone who grows it in the colder northern areas love it.

Very few people seem to recognize the fact that colder weather is how you control it. Grow it in a tropical environment like Florida where it never gets cold and you’re going to look like Seymour from Little Shop of Horrors.  Tokyo, where I am,  gets a light coating of snow every winter, so we’re going to have to be careful with it.

On the other hand, the Japanese in Tokyo would have this invasive for breakfast. Put it in a container plant and it’s not going anywhere. You can take an axe to it.

Korean Natural Farming Indigenous Microorganisms IMO

The following article is taken from Korean Natural Farming Handbook p.91 to 105.  Some of the English was somewhat clumsy and so the article has been edited lightly.

Indigenous Microorganisms(IMOs)

1. Why indigenous?

Natural farming rejects foreign microorganisms. It also rejects microorganisms that are produced mechanically or artificially or refined simply to increase their market values. No other microorganism adapts with the same strength and effectiveness as indigenous microorganisms that have lived in the local area for a long time.  Domestic farmers who are used to buying commercial microorganisms are amazed at the effectiveness of homemade indigenous microorganisms (IMO). The spread of IMOs and Fermented Plant Juice (FPJ) is giving a new vision for environment friendly agriculture in Asia. We can make microorganisms, widely considered to be one of the most important materials in sustainable agriculture, at home.

IMO is the basis of making fertile soil.

Farming is inconceivable without soil. Therefore adding strength and fertility to soil is the number one priority. What then is fertile soil? Current research indicates that 0.1 hectare of uncontaminated land holds around 700 kg of microorganisms, although this varies depending on how much organic material  is contained in the soil. Of this, 70-75% is fungus, 20-25% is bacteria and 5% is small animals. If we assume that around 80% of their body mass is water then the dry weight would be about 140kg.  Of this dry weight Carbon (C) accounts for 70kg and nitrogen accounts for around 11kg. Given that the suggested nitrogen fertilizer input for 0.1 ha is 10kg we can see that the amount of naturally produced nitrogen in the soil is equivalent.

100 million to 1 billion microorganisms live in 1 gram of soil. In the space of 1 human footprint are to be found 3,280 aphids, 479 fleas, 74,810 nematodes and 1,485 small earthworms. All these organisms live in balance, helping the growth of plants on the land’s surface.

For environmentally friendly agriculture to be successful we need to replicate these conditions as much as possible. In order to bring soil into balance as described above strategies for creating adequate conditions and food for microorganisms and small animals is essential. When you cover hard packed soil  with straw mats and straw for 7-10 days you will witness white fungus proliferating and the soil itself becoming soft and wet.  These conditions never fail to attract earthworms. Thus adding expensive purchased microorganisms to the soil is unnecessary, with some minimal input from humans the soil can recover its strength on its own. In a proper environment (Ian:not sure what this means) fungus microrganisms grow first. Their growth attracts nematodes, which in turn attract earthworms, mole crickets and moles. These organisms and animals restore the balance to soil, improve it’s structure and condition and so help the growth of plants.  90% of the organisms beneficial to plants live within 5cm of the soil’s surface.

When the land is covered by organic material such as rice straw an ideal ratio of shade to sun, 7:3 is created.  Under such conditions water is kept from evaporating and the soil is protected from direct sunlight.  In order to create such an environment a variety of methods are utilized including rice straw or leaf mulching, wild grass cultivation mulching and rye sowing.

You will see from looking at mountains and fields in nature that the land becomes fertile from top to bottom, not bottom to top. Therefore it is recommended that organic fertilizers and organic materials be applied to the surface of the soil in the form of mulching.

Material Circulation

Microorganisms do most of the material circulation in nature (Ian: this is also referred to as the soil food web). These microorganisms break down materials by decomposition as well as creating new materials.  Seemingly nothing is impossible for microorganisms.

Microorganisms in soil are responsible for two main functions.

The first function is to decompose and convert complex organic compounds such as dead plant and animals, numerous secretions and excretions and organic fertilizers into simple compounds such that material circulation is possible.  Inorganic nutrients are also decomposed by organisms and become highly activated and easily absorbed by plants . Weak microorganism action means improper material circulation.

The second function is to synthesize complex compounds and organic compounds. Microorganisms produce a wide variety of such compounds including antibiotics, enzymes and lactic acids. These suppress various diseases and promote chemical reactions in the soil. In the absence of enzymes complex chemical reactions cannot occur at high speed. For example when sunlight strikes leaves it takes less than 1 second to produce one molecule of carbohydrate. Most chemical reactions in the soil and in plants are not likely to occur without enzymes acting as catalysts.  Some microorganisms self synthesize nutrients using energy from sunlight, some fix nitrogen obtained from the air and so enrich the soil.

Many more microorganisms and functions exist which we are not aware of.  Modern scientific knowledge has revealed less than 10% of the soils microorganisms. The soil and the microorganisms which inhabit it remain for the most part a mystery.

Commercialization of microrganisms

As more research is done on microorganisms so there is ever greater pressure to commercialize them. The result has been that large amounts of microorganisms are imported from foreign countries an sold on the domestic market. This is regrettable.

One core issue is how microorganisms can be commercialized. Commercialization is only possible when you can be assured of continued sales and demand.  However this also means that the effectiveness of commercially sold microrganisms be short lived.  And so it is that commercialized microorganisms are indeed short lived  and effective only in the short term. Such microrganisms are short lived because they perish in local soil to which they are not accustomed.

As more emphasis is put on environment friendly agriculture an ever increasing number of of these microorganism products will appear on the market. As a farmer myself I would likely to clearly communicate to farmers that “the best microorganisms come from the local environment and so what you need is all around you and readily available”.

Power of the Indigene

IMO’s have evolved over thousands of years to survive and adapt to the conditions in the local environment. They can withstand the extreme climactic conditions that the environment throws at them. Within their home environment they will perform their function powerfully. Artificially made or imported microorganisms will not perserve in harsh environments to which they are not accustomed and so will die, resulting in short term effects only.

Microorganisms that are made in factories or greenhouses where temperature and moisture are kept constant are only effective in similar environments but NOT where the environmentt is different of subject to change. In the greenhouse there are no typhoons, droughts or floods, but farming has to deal with all kinds of unexpected environmental conditions.  Korean Natural Farming suggests therefore that farmers grow and use local microorganisms at ambient temperatures. I firmly believe that there is no better alternative to using  locally available IMO’s on your fields.

Restoring nature to its pristine state

Some farmers percieve microorganisms to be like fertilizers and vitamins. Acting on this they add microorganisms to the land at a time they think suitable in pursuit of short term effects. In the short run this can give them the results theyu seek. However, in the long term, it can disrupt the balance within a pristine ecosystem of microrganisms.

Korean Natural Farming does not recommend using micro-organisms for a particular function. We believe it is better to restore the pristine state in order to obtain resilience in diversity and restore the soil’s primitive power.

We have to understand that ever more complicated and mechanical, i.e artificial, ways of thinking in farming is only making farming more difficult. The philosophy of restoring the pristine by contrast is very similar to the “Tao” of Lau Tzu. [Ian: An appreciation of nature as a designer is evident in the ‘new’ discipline of biomimicry.]

Plants excretions differ in quality and amount according by season and by age. In turn, the type and amount of microrganisms that live on these excretions also change across seasons.

Bamboo Forests and Leaf Molds abound in IMO

If you look at brushwood fences, bamboo forests or mountain valleys where leaves are piled you will find the white growth of microorganisms. Microorganisms find their best living environments on their own. Farmers in the past would make fertilizer by collecting soil containing decomposed leaves or grass sheets. Below the decomposed leaves or grass sheets IMO abounds.

IMOs are easily found and collected in bamboo forest, deciduous forests, grass roots, decomposed leaf molds etc. In Korean Natural Farming we collect, grow and utilize these IMOs in many different ways.  This treasure exists within our grasp, wherever we may be.

2. Using IMOs

Loss of diversity in microorganisms means that plants lose resistance to diseases. Continued use of indigenous microorganisms not only makes soil and plants healthy but also prevents diseases.

Use IMOs continuously

After practising Korean Natural Farming techniques for 2-3 years you can get lazy with regard to collecting and making IMOs. This laziness begins with the premature assessment that the fields have improved to the point where the effort is no longer necessary.  From there it is a short step to the decision that a little bit of rice wine or lactic acid bacteria will suffice. However, this is far from true.

The MOST important thing in the soil is the primitive diversity and power of indigenous microorganisms. Farmers who fail to use IMOs properly cannot expect to see continued results. Relying on  few substances such as rice wine, despite its being natural, can contribute to disturbing the balance.

Diversity is essential

Modern science was faced with a dilemma as it found out more and more about microorganisms. At first microorganisms were classified into two categories; the good and the bad.  Scientists tried to selectively use what they considered the beneficial ones. Many of the bacteria products you see on the market today are the results of such efforts. However further research has revealed that it is very difficult to classify microorganisms as either good or bad. Additionally, it is extremely difficult to achieve sustained, long term, safe effects using selective microorganisms. It would be fair to say that “the use of indigenous microorganisms is both the simplest and the wisest method”.

Use the tough guy

Anyone who has used IMOs has observed the difference in performance levels of IMOs collected from different regions. IMO’s on the sunny side and the shaded side of the same mountain display differences. They also differ according to the altitude at which they are collected and according to soil fertility.  If you wish to add some tough guys into your locally collected IMO add some collected from high mountains or uncontaminated pristine nature with high vital energy.

The power of diversity

The more sterilized your soil is the fewer microorganisms it will have. This ‘vaccuum of power’ is an invitation for disease causing bacteria to propagate explosively. A web of lively and diverse microorganisms provides the necessary checks and balances preventing this from occurring.  Diseases do not come to you, you invite them in.

If you wish to use diversity to improve your rice crop then you should collect microorganisms that dissolve silicic acid.  Rice absorbs large amounts of silicic acid.  The plant uses this to harden its body. [Ian: the silica content of rice husks and such is so high that research is being conducted on how to use the silica from rice for silicon chips and solar panels. It also causes breathing problems when rice husks are burned in the open air].  Reed,bamboo, purple eulalia lophatherum gracile have similarly hard bodies. The roots of these plants produce a special root acid that dissolves (and absorbs) silicic acid. Thus if you collect leaf or soil from around these plants  it will greatly improve your rice crop.

In the nothern hemisphere the north face of a mountain has lot of psychrophiles (organisms capable of growth and reproduction in cold temperatures), while the south face has mesophiles and thermophiles (medium and high temperatures respectively). On the north face there are no high temperature bacteria  with a fermentation temperature above 70 degrees C,  however you will have  a chance to find them on the south facing slope. Low temperature bacteria will help your crops in cloudy weather, long periods of rainfall and low temperatures. Conversely, high temperature bacteria will help your crops in sunny weather, droughts and high temperatures.

So what do we do? We collect leaf mould and soil from all four faces of the mountain, from the summit, the valley and the drench. [Ian: I assume that the drench is a part of the mountain which is continually waterlogged.] We then mix it and culture it in rice bran.

3. How to collect IMOs

IMOs can be collected using a variety of methods. It can be collected from hills and mountains using steamed rice with low moisture (i.e. hard boiled) , decomposed leaves and bamboo stumps. It is also possible to collect, to a certain extent, particular types of microorganisms.

Collecting from the forest

1.  Fill a wooden lunchbox (preferably made from Japanese cedar) with hard steamed rice. [Ian: I assume Japanese cedar because it is waterproof and decay resistant. I see it used in Onsen a lot.] This rice should not be packed deeper than 7cm to ensure air permeates through to the bottom, preventing anaerobic bacteria from proliferating. Aerobic microorganisms are more commonly recommended.

2. Cover the lunchbox with rough paper (so that the air can get through) and tie it to the box with a rubber band.

3. Bury the lunchbox in the local bamboo field or in decomposed leaf moulds in the hills. Cover it with leaves, Ensure that the leaves are in contact with the paper such that the paper touches the rice surface.

4. Lay down a plastic sheet on top of the leaves above the lunchbox to prevent the rain from getting in.

5. At 20 degrees it will take about 4-5 days (faster when hotter) for the IMOs to fill the box. At this point in time you should move the rice (called IMO1) to a clay pot.

6. Mix the rice with an equal amount of crude (or brown) sugar. The resultant mixture is called IMO2.

7. Cover the clay pot with paper and secure it with a rubber band.

Collecting from leaf mould

1. Go to the hills, forests, valleys and you will find leaf moulds full of white hypha. [Ian: Hypha is also called mycelium and Paul Stamets, the world renowned Mycological expert uses this term.] Collect this IMO mould. Deciduous forests are better as evergreen forests have fewer microorganisms.

2. Dip hard steamed rice in a solution of FPJ [Fermented Plant Juice-coming soon on this blog] diluted at 1:1000 with water. Warm it and then leave it to cool.

3. Mix this rice with the leaf mould. Leave for one night.

4. Add this mixture to rice bran for propagation. Cover the rice bran with rice straw to promote IMO growth.

5. You can add FPJ,  FAA [Fish Amino Acid],mineral A, etc to boost the process.

Collecting from bamboo stumps

1. Choose a bamboo tree in the centre of the bamboo forest.  Cut it down. Cut into the trunk 10cm up from the ground. Cut obliquely with the deeper part of the cut being lower then shallow so that the bamboo sap will not leak out. You should be left with a hollow bowl on top.

2. Fill the bowl with hard boiled rice, the rice should be filled higher than the brim.

3. Put a wooden lunchbox (Japanese cedar) ove the stump.

4. Cover the lunchbox with leaves.

5. Cover with a plastic sheet, and then put a weight on top of it so that it won’t get blown off.

6. After 3-5 days the rice wil be stained  red, white, yellow and black, and all sorts of bacteria will be present. Juice from the bamboo will also be collected.

7. Cut the stump. Pour the rice into a clay pot (this is IMO 1).

8. Mix the rice with an equal amount of crude (or brown) sugar (this is IMO2).

9. Cove the clay pot with paper and secure the paper with a rubber band.

Collecting from the rice paddy

1. After the rice harvest, cover the rice stump with a filled rice lunchbox immediately after cutting. The lunchbox faces downwards.

2. Cover with steel wire to stop mice getting in.

3. Cover with a plastic sheet to stop rain from washing it all away.

4. After approximately 1 week the IMO will have worked their way into the rice.

5. Pour the rice into a clay pot (this is IMO1).

6. Add an equal amount of crude (or brown) sugar (this is IMO2).

7. Cover the clay pot with paper and secure the paper with a rubber band.

When you collect microorganisms from rice paddies, as opposed to other locations, you can obtain a lot of anaerobic (i.e. non air-breathing) microorganisms. In particular you can collect a large quantity of Bacillus Licheniformis (which actively breaks down protein, fat and carbohydrates) and Bacillus Subtilis (which  breaks down strong fibres such as rice straw, straw and reeds). Both of these microorganisms have outstanding decomposition power. However, when the fermentation temperature rises above 70 degrees C they not only convert protein into amino acid but also amino acid into ammonia. Should this occur then the nutrients turn to gas and are lost to the atmosphere. [Ian: Ammonia is also a powerful greenhouse gas]. Therefore, fermentation temperatures should be maintained at or below 50 degrees C.

Lactic acid bacteria feeds on the sugars and amino acids made by Bacillus Licheniformis and Bacillus Subtilis. Adding lactic acid bacteria lowers the temperature.

4. How to cultivate IMOs

Propagation of IMOs

1. The work must be done indoors shielded from direct sunlight; in greenhouses or warehouses.

2. Dilute IMO2 500 times with water and mix with rice bran or flour.  The moisture level of this mixture should be 65-70%. It should be a little wet to the touch. When adding water to control moisture also use diluted FPJ, FAA, Mineral A etc. for better results.

3. Pile the resulting rice bran mixture 30-40cm deep (50-70cm in a cold climate). It should not be on a concrete floor but in contact with a soil floor.

4.  Firmly cover with a straw mat, ensuring that the temperature does not rise over 50 degrees C. To ensure this does not occur turn 3-4 times.

5. Cultivation speed can vary depending on the outside temperature, but it usually takes 5-7 days for the surface to be covered with whitish IMO spores. When the temperature stops rising the fermentation process is finished and you have IMO3.

6. Mix one part IMOs3 to 1o parts rice bran

7. Now mix one part IMO3 with one part soil. 50% of the soil should be from the crop field and 50% should be from fresh new soil (mountain soil, red fine clay, etc). Doing this will ensure that the wild IMOs will harmonize with field IMOs.

8. Controlling moisture preferably with natural farming inputs.

Liquid Cultures of IMOs

1. Fill a pair of pantyhose or a fine net with IMO3. A room temperature of around 20 degrees C and a PH between 6 and * is sufficient.

2. You will then need a 250L opaque container with an air compressor.  Add 0.5L Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB), 2L Fermented Plant Juice (FPJ), 700-800 grams of brown sugar to 150-160L of water.

[Ian: Though the book seems to omit this important detail I can only assume that the net containing IMO3 is dipped into the water and the compressor turned on. This would similar to what is described on p.137 of the book Teaming with Microbes in relation to brewing ‘actively aerated compost teas’:

“some people put their compost in a porous bag before they put it into the tea brewer rather than allowing it it mix freely in the water. A pair of large sized pantyhose works well as such a compost sock.”

There appears to be a lot of crossover details between making IMOs and making actively aerated compost teas. the main differences seem to be the source materials and the IMO fermentation process as opposed to composting. ]

3. Depending on the the culture temperature the fermentation process takes between 5 and 7 days in Spring and Fall and 10 and 30 days in winter. Depending on the cultivated state the resultant mixture can smell either sweet or nasty, a sweet smell is desirable.

4. Often a sludge will appear on the surface. This sludge is composed of microorganism corpses. This can occur when food or air is lacking in the solution. If it occurs add more air, or add FPJ.

5.  Replacing the IMO in the sack every once in a while can also be beneficial.

6. Depending on need use 40-50 litres of the liquid at any one time,  refilling the tank with water while adding more food for microorganisms. The basic dilution is 1000 times, but can be as strong as 500 times  depending on the need.

[Ian: My reading of this is that the liquid in the tank should be diluted on the order of 1 part to 100o of water. Keep in mind these input instructions are designed to supply a working farm with all its fertilizer so the amounts would be huge for a garden or allotment.]

Chemical fertilizer can be added to the solution. The solution can then be used 7-10 days later after the IMO has had time to act on the chemicals. Adding too much chemical fertilizer at once can stop the fermentation process. Therefore it is important to introduce the chemical fertilizer to the tank in adequate amounts slowly. The yeast bacteria so abundant in FPJ are excellent decomposers of chemical fertilizers; converting them to easily absorbable mineral forms. Using chemical fertilizer in this way will greatly reduce soil degradation and the nutrients will also be better absorbed by plants.  To duplicate the effect of nitrogen use ammonium sulphate or urea. To duplicate the effects of phosphorus, use superphospate or double superphospate. To duplicate the effects of calcium use quick lime.

The Hanging Gardens of the Future

Green Futures, the sustainable solutions magazine, recently featured an article on the subject of urban farming.  They’re basically talking about what we here at Rooftop Ecology will soon be putting into practice.

“Every one of us will own a ‘farm in a box’, which will sit on our balcony, roof or next to a window. Advances in aeroponics – growing in a mist of nutrients, rather like in a rainforest – will give us emissions-neutral food at the heart of our cities.

These boxes would be supplemented by neighbourhood vertical farms housed in the redundant high-rise office blocks we no longer commute to, and the multi-storey carparks we no longer need. They will employ closed-loop systems, generating their own energy and harvesting and recycling rainwater. Front gardens, flat roofs and patches of wasteland will also become mini-market gardens, helping to green, cool and feed the city.

The full article is here:

http://www.forumforthefuture.org.uk/greenfutures/articles/The_hanging_gardens_of_the_future

I agree with this article for the most part. What I disagree with is the idea of having closed loop systems. Such systems tend to be envisioned rather narrowly, missing out on the possibilities that come from borders, linkage and connections.

If you accept the idea that energy and materials can neither be created not destroyed, merely turned into different forms, then closed systems would be stifling in its constraints. I tend to side with ZERI on this – ZERI methodology is more of an attempt at an infinite cycle, constantly using energy from the sun and material from the earth’s surface and oceans to power an ever more complex of beneficial linkages, such that absolutely nothing is wasted.

Nature is chock a block with systems of unbelievable complexity such that nothing is wasted. To think that a human designed closed system would be the ultimate is to lack vision.

Additionally, aquaponics (fish and plants in gravel) beats hydroponics (plants in solutions) into a cocked hat. The reason is that fish-plants-fish beats plants-plants. Add recyclers like earthworms, fungi and black soldier fly and you have recyclers-fish-plants-humans- and so on. You can’t get complexity if you restrict yourself to ‘just’ growing plants. Plants use animals, algae, fungi to complete their cycles, so we should also.

Furthermore, looking at it as being merely a food growing process is to miss out on the energy channeling potential. For the moment forget energy generation, think energy reduction because a NEGAWATT is so much cheaper to obtain than a MEGAWATT. Plants will perform this service for free, while doing everything else – it doesn’t get much cheaper than free.

So you see, these processes we’re developing also make buildings better. The benefits spread out to society and particularly to infrastructure:

The ultimate goal is infrastructure lite.

Also Emission Neutral? Plants remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, some of it can get back there but you can slow the process down a lot. Additionally some of the carbon taken in by plants can be turned into biochar and sequestered in the soil for hundreds, perhaps thousands of years. That’s getting into the heavy carbon negative territory. I removing carbon from the atmosphere and putting it into the soil in a form that doesn’t lead back to the atmosphere again.

Biochar

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biochar

Finally, “Box” is a particularly inappropriate concept in this regard, because what we’re talking about has no walls or boundaries. Use “infinite webs” instead. Some might say you can’t design the infinite. I say look at the the massive networks we have which are composed of simple units connected to each other – one example would be the internet.

Carolyn Steel talking about how food shapes cities.

Here is Carolyn Steel talking about how food shaped cities and about how food can reshape cities so that they are ready for the future.

Rooftop Ecology System Notes

Food Waste in…

1. Processed by

Black Soldier Fly

Earthworms

Rabbits

Chickens

2. Black Soldier Fly

40% conversion – organic waste to black soldier fly larvae

Protein, Fat  used in systems

Chitin out (there is a market for chitin)

Fly larvae fed to fish (replacing fish meal in a aquaponics system)

Fly larvae fed to chickens (again replacing protein supplements).

The metabolisms of the larvae generate significant heat, apparently enough to keep warms away. I am toying with the notion of having the bin help keep the fish tank warm. Waste heat needs to be considered a resource in systems.

3. Earthworms

Interesting fact: Earthworms grow faster when fed on Black Soldier Fly secretions.

Earthworms produce vermicompost and wormcasts. This produces the resources allowing the system to practically self-replicate.

Earthworms also produce enzymes, used for industrial cleaners (to market)

The worm tea obtained by soaking the vermicompost would be added to the water supply for the self irrigated planters. There’s some concern on my part as to whether this could be dispensed into the common water supply feeding the irrigation spaces at the bottom of the SIP system, or whether it would be better to dispense it into the soil from above.

4. Chickens

Chicken meat (food)

Chicken Eggs (food)

Chicken Shells (Korean Natural Farming Agro Input)

Chicken Manure (to composter)

Chicken Innards (to Black Soldier Fly)

Chicken feathers (possibility of using it to replace wood pulp in paper and hydrocarbons in plastic)

Chicken Bones (to Korean Natural Farming DIY inputs)

5. Rabbits

Rabbit meat.

Rabbit meat is very low in fat, generally in the 4% range. By contrast be, chicken and turkey are in the 20% range with pork up in the high 30s to low 40s.  Also, as a meat animal rabbits are very easy to process.  That being said every effort to make sure the rabbits are not cruelly treated should be taken. From a moral standpoint I tend to agree with the inuit and tribal groups who feel that harvesting animals for meat is fine so long as there is an agreement that you will act for the benefit of the species.

Rabbit fur (dunno clothes maybe?)

Rabbit fur is a bit of a problem I think. PETA and similar organizations are opposed to  industrial rabbit farming techniques, quite rightly I feel. However, this seems likely to impact small polyculture enterprises that treat their animals well. I need to learn more about space requirements and handling procedures to ensure happy and content rabbits.

Rabbit Innards (to black soldier fly)

I am against turning herbivores into carnivores. You never know, it could be that I have the human variant of BSE slowing ticking away in my head because farmers were feeding spinal cord and brain tissue direct to cattle. Though I’m no expert I think if such things are processed through one of more intermediary stages of consumption the risks would be greatly reduced. I’m a firm believer in the utility of ZERI’s five kingdom thinking.

(The five kingdoms are detailed here: http://www.zeri.org/about_science_five_kingdoms.htm)

6.  Aquaponic Fish and Vegetables

Everything I read about aquaponics suggests that it is a highly productive, zero waste system for growing plants.  Water is heavy however, so I imagine its use on roofs would be limited in scope. On the other hand it appears that water plants like Azolla could flourish in such a system, apparently the only limiting factor for explosive Azolla growth is phosphorus. However Korean natural farming techniques detail DIY techniques which allow the recovery of phosphorus in animal bones and from sesame plants. I like the idea. I’ve always been in awe of the way the Sioux and other native tribes people have a use for every part of a creature, for me it shows respect and this is missing from industrial farming.

7. Self Irrigated Planter


I’ve been impressed by details on the net about how to DIY build Self Irrigated Planters (or SIPS).In connection with this I’ve been looking at perennial plants to put into them. Given that annuals might be better grown in the aquaponics system. Here’s a list of the plants that have attracted my attention thus far. I then need to see which ones could be grouped together into guilds, by that I mean the permaculture term for grouping companion plants together into collaborative communities. 

The List:

Uñi http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Ugni+molinae

Nepalese Raspberry http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Rubus+nepalensis

Loganberry http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Rubus+loganobaccus

Oregon Cut-Leaf Blackberry http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Rubus+laciniatus

Raspberry http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Rubus+idaeus

Blackberry http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Rubus+fruticosus

Jostaberry http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Ribes+x+culverwellii

Gooseberry http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Ribes+uva-crispa

Blackcurrant http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Ribes+nigrum

French Scorzonera (Important) http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Reichardia+picroides

Breadroot http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Psoralea+esculenta

Goldenberry (all parts except fruit (including fruit covering) are poisonous

http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Physalis+peruviana

Yampa http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Perideridia+gairdneri

Chinese Mallow (do not grow in nitrogen rich soils) (Important) http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Malva+verticillata

Musk Mallow (do not grow in nitrogen rich soils) (Important) http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Malva+moschata

Malva Alcea (do not grow in nitrogen rich soils) (Important) http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Malva+alcea

Maca http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Malva+alcea

Sweet Potato (vine) http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Ipomoea+batatas

Hemerocallis varieties

http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Hemerocallis+middendorffii+esculenta

http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Hemerocallis+middendorffii

http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Hemerocallis+fulva

Shallon http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Gaultheria+shallon

Fennel http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Foeniculum+vulgare

Alpine strawberry (edible leaves) http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Fragaria+vesca+%27Semperflorens%27

Squash http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Cucurbita+moschata

Winter Squash http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Cucurbita+maxima

Campanula Versicolor (Important) http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Campanula+versicolor

Broccoli http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Brassica+oleracea+italica

Sea Orach http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Atriplex+halimus

Quebec Berry http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Amelanchier+stolonifera

Wild Garlic http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+ursinum

Garlic Chives http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+ursinum

Three cornered leek http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+triquetrum

Giant Chives http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+schoenoprasum+sibiricum

Chives http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+schoenoprasum

Serpent Garlic http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+schoenoprasum

Garlic http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+sativum

Few flowered leek http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+sativum

Daffodil Garlic http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+sativum

Welsh Onion http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+fistulosum

Nodding Onion http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+fistulosum

Shallot http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+fistulosum

Onion http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+cepa

Canadian Garlic http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+canadense+mobilense

Wild Leek http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Allium+ampeloprasum

Anise Hyssop http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Agastache+foeniculum

Kiwi fruit http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Actinidia+deliciosa

Tara Vine http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Actinidia+arguta

Echinacea http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Echinacea+purpurea

Wu Wei Zi (climbing vine) http://www.pfaf.org/database/plants.php?Schisandra+chinensis

Some of these climbers I’d like to stick on a wall net, mixing male and females of the same species…

8. Wall Nets

This is just something that occurred to me. I spend a lot of time looking at buildings in Tokyo, which is a pity because the architecture is simply awful. The reason I do this is because of the surfaces. The tiled surfaces on many of these buildings are beautiful. While doing this, and not walking around in an I-pod stupor (I swear I-pod means that it’s a place where you store your personality, for me it’s like solitary confinement without walls) I noted that a lot of walls were windowless and bathed in sunlight. Often the walls led down to a small space on the ground where a net could be anchored, and up to a roof where the other net hooks could find a home.  It also occurred to me that some vines like a lot of direct sunlight and others not so much. I then wonderered whether you could layer nets up and down the wall, and construct them like venetian blinds so that you could raise and lower the nets and pick your hardy kiwi off it. I’d imagine for vines coming down from the roof anchoring the SIPs down securely would be vital. The idea of a heavy vine pulling its SIP off the roof is the stuff of nightmares.

9. Beehive

Urban bees seem to be having a much easier time than country bees. What I’ve read suggests that bees prefer a vast choice of flowers to a thousand acre field of rapeseed. I came across information on the net about how to self build beehives. I have a book on order though.

10. Coffee grounds and Oyster Mushrooms

There’s no shortage of coffee shops in Tokyo. There’s also no shortage of dark narrow spaces between apartment buildings in Tokyo. Some are so narrow that I swear the architects wanted cats to have some private space. On the other hand I think it could be useful space for growing oyster mushrooms, with the spent strata getting mixed with the vermicompost and added to the SIPS.

Other considerations..

I’m investigating whether it’s possible to combine a worm bin and a bsf bin, into a multiple compartment device.  I dislike the thought of having to transfer BSF compost to the worm bin. Why not have a segregated big bin where the worms would go into a compartment after the BSF were finished eating and had been drawn into a separate cell? Anyway, just something to look into.

Vegetable Fungi Polyculture

I read in Paul Stamet’s amazing book Mycelium Running that a researcher associated with his company experimented with plant/mushroom polycultures.  The results were pretty impressive.  It’s something I’d like to put on roofs,  to get two crops from the one pot, especially given that mycelium aerates soil,  digests waste products from plants etc etc .

Problem is, I don’t really have much of an idea of how to do it. However on another blog site site “Farmer Scrub’s Blog”:

http://farmerscrub.blogspot.com/2006_12_01_archive.html

I came across this plan he has…

“Grow oyster mushrooms in buckets of coffee grounds, which we get for free from two local coffee places. We should be able to use our fruiting oyster mushrooms as inoculant for the grounds.”

It occurs to me that if these oyster mushrooms could also be grown in polyculture with vegetables then I would be closer to my ideal of connecting plants, animals, bacteria, fungi and algae in a zero waste (bountiful) ecosystem on a roof. Buckets could be in dark places. I’d wondered what I could use the narrow completely shadowed spaces between apartments for.  Could be an answer.

Korean Natural Farming Water-Soluble Calcium

Taylor and I are looking to build Rooftop Ecologies.  In these ecologies as in all ecologies the waste product of organism is food for another organism within the network. It’s one of ZERI’s  (Zero Emissions Research and Initiatives) core principles. What it amounts to in our case is the waste stream we divert through our system should be organic. The organisms that use things from this waste stream should utilize it to make things and provide services to biodiversity, any waste they issue post processing should be food for something else so that in the end bad things go in but nothing bad comes out the other end.

Korean Natural Farming Techniques shows how to use eggshells (a waste product) to improve the health of the plants we will grow on rooftops and down the walls of buildings.  Some of these plants will also be fruit bearing. It’s something you can do with the eggs you get from the chickens we’ll have on the roof.  It’s just another way to turn what most people regard as rubbish into gold. Now all I have to do is figure out how to make the vinegar.

Here’s page 133 of the Natural Farming handbook:

Calcium contributes to the better utilization of carbohydrates and protein; it is also a major element in forming a cell membrane; and enables smooth cell division. Calcium also bonds with organic acid to rid the body of harmful substances. Calcium prevents the overgrowth of crops, hardens the fruit, prolongs the storage period, promotes crop absorption of phosporic acid and helps crops accumulate nutrients.

How to make WCA

1. Collect eggshells and take the inside skin off.

2. Pound the shells.

3. Lightly roast the shells to remove any organic substances that can rot.

4. Put the roasted shells in a container filled with brown rice vinegar (BRV). The eggshell fragments will move up and and down  in the solution emitting bubbles until all the calcium is dissolved into the solution. When there is no more movement or bubbles, it is done. If there are no more bubbles but eggshell fragments remain it means the solution is saturated.

5. In some cases, shrimp or crab shells maybe be added to improve the effect and elvan powder may also be added (one handful per 18 litres of BRV)

How to use WCA

There are expensive, imported water soluble calcium supplements on the market. You would think that this cheap WCA would not be as effective as these. But your concerns will cease after a single application. The power of this can be strengthened by mixing Oriental Herb Nutrients (OHN) [details of this will come in a future post].

This WCA is effective in converting plants lifecycle from vegetative to reproductive growth. Natural Farmers spray WCA on the leaves after the fruits have become large. It prevents overgrowth and you get a sweet hard fruit. WCA also strengthens the flower bud ensuring that you get good fruits this year and a high yield the next year. Use with water soluble Calcium Phosphate (more on this later as well), false acacia fermented plant juice (FPJ) OHN and seawater and you will have a better tasting and more aromatic fruit.

As crops enter the later stages of their life cycle they need calcium, salt and a variety of minerals. Calcium and salt are very important for plant health.  To disregard this need and focus only on NPK is wrong and the effects can be seen everywhere.

Calcium moves carbohydrate from the body (leaf and branch) to the fruit. It is effective when crops have overgrown,leaves have a bad color or no shine, floral differentiation is weak, flower blossoms just fall, fruit doesn’t ripen and or the fruit is not sweet.

[taken from p.133 and p. 134 of Dr. Cho’s Natural Farming Handbook. Dr. Cho Han Kyu is the founder of the Janong Natural Farming Institute in South Korea)

New Week New People

Another week and some progress to report.

Last night (23rd September) Taylor and I met Mami, a very nice young Japanese woman. She seemed taken with our ideas and proposals.  She is skilled in woodwork, and her brother is building his own house. He sounds like someone we should meet as well. Could be that two will become three.  Still trying to get our core skills group together at this point.

Brandon Pitcher, one of our advisors, is getting me the contact details for a lady in Chicago who is the brains behind a rooftop farm on top of a restaurant. Brandon was telling me that it’s the first certified organic rooftop farm in North America.  I think that’s some indication of how new this all is. I look forward to having a dialogue with her.

Brandon is also recommending I email someone called Neal Bennett. I googled the name, wouldn’t we all, and it turns out he’s an environmental scientist with Butler, Fairman and Seufert in Indiana. Sounds high powered and expensive. I would hate to be a burden, but maybe I wouldn’t be. We’re in the same boat after all. Our life support systems are connected.

Additionally, I exchanged e-mails with Flavio Souza over at Greeniters.com and he’s now asking around for people who have a roof.  He wrote to me that he knew someone with an unused and unsellable bathtub. Sounds like a fish tank to me.  Problem is that it’s over in someplace called Sagamiko in Kanagawa, which apparently is a fair old distance from downtown Tokyo. So we need to arrange transport. On the other hand we do need to have the roof first or it would be like putting the baby before the bathwater if you’ll pardon the pun.

Like most people he was asking about the weight issue, and this is a highly relevant question to ask. The simple answer is neither Taylor or I know anything about weight limits on structures and so we need to get a structural engineer or architect on the team. It occurs to me that the question is not merely how much weight, but how is it distributed. Wondering if there’s ways to spread the weight of heavy items over a greater area of roof? On that note Marion Stewart over at:

http://www.articlesbase.com/gardening-articles/balcony-rooftop-gardens-1180498.html

…suggests “Spreading the load over a wide area using wooden slats, brackets and hooks to take the weight of hanging pots or baskets”. This makes sense to me, but it’s just something else I have to research in order to incorporate it into the system. Wooden slats sounds like something that Mami would know how to put together.

Gerry Gillespie over at Zero Waste I nternational Alliance (ZWIA) sent me a note saying he was glad to hear I’d started my own group.  It’s early days yet being just Taylor and me, but as the Joker says in the Dark Knight

“Now, our operation is small, but there’s a lot of potential for “aggressive” expansion. So, which one of you fine gentlemen would like to join our team?”

I’m hoping that I don’t have to use a very sharp broken pool cue to prove my points.

Gerry was telling me there’s a conference with a video uplink happening in November. I need to sign up for that.  ZWIA and another group the Asian Network of Organic Recyclers (ANOR) are fine upstanding organizations, full of people committed to taking better care of the planet.

David Baird, a fellow teacher here in Tokyo, knows someone in the Tokyo Municipal Government. It could be we could talk to him and see about waste streams. People who have to deal with it on a day to day basis would be excellent sources of information on where the waste flows freely and where it needs to be dealt with.  I need to get in contact with David again. Could be we find a waste stream we find roof, if we can convince the waste streamers that we can help.

In Tokyo the other people orbiting around the Taylor-Ian binary star, shedding our light in a very dark and forbidding universe, include Sebastian (a German with a sense of humor, yeah I know) and Micah (an American). They’re orbiting pretty far out at the moment, truly dark satellites, but are both clever and creative people. They’re up for a drink a lot of the time. Taylor and I need to get something started pretty soonish or everyone will think that we’re all talk and no action. I would hate for that to happen.

Yesterday I learned that if you feed biochar to pigs the biochar gets mixed with the manure and so can be applied to soils more easily. I also learned that it cuts down on flatulence in farm animals.  Sounds like a double whammy for Greenhouse Gas Reduction. Now if only people could get me to stop talking about this stuff I might qualify for carbon credits.

Black Soldier Fly Links

When I spoke to people about processing food waste on roofs one comment I heard again and again was “What about the smell?” Garbage smells but somehow it’s ok if its stinking up the river or an industrial park.

“Black Soldier Fly Larvae” is now my response.  The word Fly is about as negative a word as exists in the English language. This is a pity as black soldier Flies are a beneficial fly; definitely not something that will vomit on your pizza.

They do not spread disease, because they’re not interested in either your food or your blood.

Their larvae will eat practically any food trash you can throw at it.  The black soldier fly will act as a predigester for earthworms, reducing the volume by 95% in the space of hours. The Earthworms can then get to work on it.

The larvae emit pheromone signals warning other flies to stay away. Which means that in the unlikely event of food trash lasting long enough to get stinky those pesky houseflies still won’t go near it.

When they emerge from a pupae they live for a very short time, just long enough to have a drink (they have no mouthparts for eating) and mate. They then die.  I see the parallels with bee drones, and how I wish they were called Black Bees.

The larvae having eaten their fill will climb out of the barrel for a date with hungry fish and chickens.  Humans helpfully supply the ramps for their date with destiny.

A site which includes a lot of links on the subject is here:

http://www.circle3.com/index.php?option=com_weblinks&view=category&id=2%3Absf&Itemid=30

« Older entries